Da Legal Stuff...

All commentaries published on Web Talk are the opinions of the contributor(s) only and do not necessarily represent the position of any other individuals, groups or organizations.

Now, with that out of the way...Let's Web Talk.

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Loyola Hearn & John Efford - Two of a Kind.



"Take it or leave it." - Federal Liberal cabinet minister John Efford attempting to pressure the province of Newfoundland and Labrador into accepting an Atlantic Accord deal that would have included a cap tied to Ontario's fiscal capacity (the same sort of cap now introduced in the federal Conservatives budget).

John Efford conveniently retired from politics within months of that comment and did not run in the following election.

"The province is losing nothing now, We have until 2012 with the Atlantic Accord benefits uncapped..." - Loyola Hearn attempting to sell the new Harper budget (including a fiscal cap) to Newfoundland and Labrador on March 20 2007.

Already there are calls for Loyola Hearn's resignation in the wake of the federal budget and his clear support for it. During an interview Hearn also went on the offensive blaming the provinces for not agreeing to the plan his PM hoped to put in place and warned premier williams that any anti-election campaign he might have in mind "works both ways". That sort of threat might not have been a politically astute move in reference to a sitting premier who is supported by nearly 75% of the electorate. It might just backfire and help rally the troops against Mr. Hearn. Time will tell.

At least Conservative member Norm Doyle had the intelligence, just days before the federal budget was delivered, to announce that he wouldn't be running in the next election. Tell me Loyola, is your cushy cabinet position really worth the price of selling out your people? I hope so because I doubt you'll be sitting in that after the next election.

Simply put, Stephen Harper and his government members broke a written promise made to several premiers of Canada. Whether anyone agrees with the premise of removing non-renewable resource revenues from equalization calculations or not, it doesn't take away the fact that the Prime Minister lied to the premiers of the provinces in writing and he is being supported in his lies by MPs who were elected by the people of those provinces.

It's one thing to go door to door in an election campaign and smoothly lead people to believe you are concerned with their issues. All politicians do that. They all use words like, "I'll take that under advisement" or "I fully support that concept and once elected I'll see what I can do". They all do that but they don't all put a clear cut promise in writing, sign on the dotted line and have that written promised delivered to the premiers of 3 provinces, one of whom was the head of the federation of provinces at the time.

While the common approach taken by candidates is reprehensible, the approach taken by Stephen Harper and supported by his MPs is nothing less than treason.

Canada is a federation. It is based on the concept that all the proivinces are partners and that the leaders of each province (the first ministers) play a pivotal role in the federation. What do the recent actions of Stephen Harper, Loyola Hearn and the other members of the Conservative governement who support an out and out lie to the premiers of the provinces. What does it say that this government made written committment in order to get elected and then broke that committment in order to ensure that they would get re-elected?

Loyola Hearn isn't the only one who should resign. The entire Conservative government should be forced to resign in shame, much the same way U.S. president Richard Nixon resigned during the Watergate scandal in the 1970's.

If they don't resign of their own accord serious consideration should be given to removing them all from office and perhaps even laying charges in connection with the elections act, or has the Country gone so far down hill that buying votes has become not only legal but acceptable?

If you would like to let Loyola Hearn know how you feel about his stand on the equalization issue you can email him at: Hearn.L@parl.gc.ca

Press Release: Government of Newfoundland and Labrador

Executive Council
March 20, 2007

Premier Williams says "A Promise Made is Not a Promise Kept "for Newfoundland and Labrador

The following are quotations from Prime Minister Stephen Harper (then-opposition leader) in the House of Commons during a debate on November 4, 2004 (over the Atlantic Accord):

"This is a commitment that was made by me in my capacity as leader of the Canadian Alliance when I first arrived here and has its origins in the intentions of the Atlantic accord signed by former Prime Minister Mulroney in the mid-1980s. These are longstanding commitments, our commitment to 100% of non-renewable resource royalties. It was our commitment during the election, before the election, and it remains our commitment today."

"The eight year time limit and the Ontario clause effectively gutted the commitment made to the people of Newfoundland and Labrador during the election campaign. Why should Newfoundland's possibility of achieving levels of prosperity comparable to the rest of Canada be limited to an artificial eight year period? Remember in particular that these are in any case non-renewable resources that will run out. Why is the government so eager to ensure that Newfoundland and Labrador always remain below the economic level of Ontario?"

"The Ontario clause is unfair and insulting to the people of Newfoundland and Labrador, and its message to that province, to Nova Scotia and to all of Atlantic Canada is absolutely clear. They can only get what they were promised if they agree to remain have not provinces forever. That is absolutely unacceptable."

"What is at stake is the future of Atlantic Canada, an unprecedented and historic opportunity for those provinces to get out of the have not status that has bedevilled them for decades. What is at issue is very simple. It is the honour of the Prime Minister (Paul Martin), and all he has to do is keep his word."

The assertion by Prime Minister Stephen Harper yesterday that his election promise has been delivered to the people of Newfoundland and Labrador is fundamentally wrong and misleading and the people of Canada should be wary of any promises made to them by the Harper Government.

The Honourable Danny Williams today reacted to a letter sent to him by Prime Minister Harper yesterday in which the Prime Minister claims to have lived up to his repeated commitment to remove non-renewable resource revenues from the equalization formula.

"The Prime Minister of this country came to our province on repeated occasions when he was the Leader of the Opposition and he made a promise," said Premier Williams. "The promise did not have caveats or qualifications. It was a principled-based promise that stated that natural resource revenues would be removed from the equalization formula. Stephen Harper came into our province and said essentially here is my promise to you; elect me and my party and we will give you more than what you have now, because it is the right thing to do. Yesterday, Prime Minister Harper told the people of Newfoundland and Labrador and essentially the people of Canada that his promises do not matter. His promises do not count, and they most certainly cannot be relied upon."

One example of the many written commitments can be seen in the Prime Minister’s letter to Premier Williams during the last federal election - http://www.gov.nl.ca/releases/2006/exec/0116n03.htm.

"A promise made is not a promise kept. I find it offensive and unbelievable that we are now being criticized by the federal government and others for simply asking the Prime Minister to live up to his commitment. Not partially, or with trap doors and caveats, but to truly live up to his commitment. If he does not live up to this clear election promise, then every Canadian should think long and hard about any promise made to them."

Premier Williams said the options outlined in the federal budget yesterday whereby provinces can choose the manner in which equalization is applied to their province, is an intricate game of smoke and mirrors, including a fiscal capacity cap which nullifies the Prime Minister’s commitment to remove non-renewable resources.

"While the federal government gives the illusion of allowing provinces to opt for a 100 per cent exclusion of natural resource revenue-based formula, they shrewdly immediately apply a fiscal capacity cap on that formula," added Premier Williams. "This negates the benefits of using the 100 per cent removal formula. It is terribly misleading and disingenuous, and I am quite frankly appalled that the Prime Minister and his government would betray the voters in this way."
Premier Williams said back when his government was negotiating with the previous Liberal government for the new Atlantic Accord, Stephen Harper vehemently opposed such a fiscal capacity cap.

"The absolute about face of Stephen Harper is nothing short of betrayal. It also flies in the face of what he fought for before the people of this country elected him as their Prime Minister," said the Premier.

Premier Williams acknowledged that for this year, the province is not worse off and Atlantic Accord benefits are not being eroded. But status quo was not what the Prime Minister promised, and long-term that seriously erodes the Prime Minister’s promise.

"There has been a breach of trust here, whereby we see our province being seriously disadvantaged. Other provinces that were promised nothing are getting tremendous benefits from this federal budget and the new changes to equalization. And we applaud them and congratulate them on this. However, our province and others to whom promises were made are left high and dry, yet we look unreasonable because we are asking for a promise to be kept? It is a very sad day for this federation."

Media contact:Elizabeth Matthews
Director of Communications
Office of the Premier
709-729-3960, 351-1227
elizabethmatthews@gov.nl.ca

Federal Conservatives Buy Votes at Expense of Smaller Provinces

Stephen Harper Lies to the People of Newfoundland and Labrador

Thanks to the stab in the back delivered by Stephen Harper’s American style Republicans Newfoundland and Labrador could potentially lose millions in equalization funding every year from here on in. The impact of this budget won’t truly be known for years as our province dies a slow death at the hands of Ottawa.

Harper’s tricky and too cute plan to provide Ontario and Quebec with billions while offering a series of lose/lose equalization options to Newfoundland and Labrador may guarantee his government’s survival but like the cold hearted and opportunistic weasel he is, his survival will be done on the back of Canada’s poorest province.

Premier Danny Williams said the budget is a betrayal of the province, and he wants voters to punish the Conservatives in the next federal election.

"What they've done today is basically and completely shafted us," Williams told reporters. "It's scandalous what they've done, when you think of it."

Personally I can’t wait to see how the three Conservative MPs from Newfoundland and Labrador, Norman Doyle, Fabian Manning and Fisheries Minister Loyola Hearn react to this betrayal. Will they vote in favor or against their own party’s budget plan? I guess the next few days will tell us if they plan to support their people or go the route of retired Liberal MP John Efford who shafted the province for the sake of party loyalties.

One analyst noted, “This budget clearly targets urban voters. The voters Stephen Harper needs if he hopes to win the next election.”

That’s a valid comment but its hardly news. Any party hoping to win a federal election will pander to the high volume of voters in urban areas, especially those in Ontario and Quebec. Nobody can expect them to do anything else and unfortunately the political system of Canada is designed to encourage that.

I don’t personally blame any one party. The problem lies with Canada’s parliamentary system itself and that system is exactly why Newfoundland and Labrador would be far better off calling the entire confederation experiment a failure and simply moving on.

The time has come to get out of Canada before there is nothing left.

Federal parties will always pour every ounce of energy into appeasing the voters of the major urban areas, but what does that say about the future of rural areas? What does it say about the future of Newfoundland and Labrador?

The latest budget out of Ottawa was not met by any smiles in Newfoundland and Labrador, Saskatchewan, Nova Scotia, BC or New Brunswick. While a few modest improvements were included for Alberta and PEI songs of joy were spreading like syrup inside Ontario and Quebec. Enough said.

When a federal government brings forward a budget that denies it ever made a promise, no less than 6 times in writing, and adds insult to injury by actually including a fiscal cap on revenues, the same cap every Newfoundlander and Labradorian fought so hard against during the Atlantic Accord debate, our future is clear.

Our best opportunity to build our economy, pay off our debts and provide a future for our people has just been destroyed with the callous stroke of a federal pen.

There is no future for us in Canada.

Our population is in free fall.

Our resources are being raped for the benefit to other provinces.

Our revenues are clawed back at every turn.

Federal promises mean nothing, no matter the party stripe.

Ontario and Quebec control Canada and they will always guide government policy and budgets.

Our fisheries are being mismanaged into oblivion.

We may not have a say on most issues in the federation but the choice to stay or leave is ours and ours alone.