Da Legal Stuff...

All commentaries published on Web Talk are the opinions of the contributor(s) only and do not necessarily represent the position of any other individuals, groups or organizations.

Now, with that out of the way...Let's Web Talk.

Wednesday, May 10, 2006

Premier Danny Williams - Master Poker Player

With what I’m about to say, I’m sure someone will accuse me of being a true blue Tory and on top of that I hate praising a sitting politician, but I’ll be damned if I won’t say what needs to be said about Newfoundland and Labrador Premier Danny Williams after his recent performance.

“Sir, I like the cut of your jib!”

Although the Province still has a lot of internal struggles to deal with (that’s an understatement), a number of major issues have arisen during Premier Danny Williams’ time in office that, more often than not, he’s addressed in a way that is in perfect harmony with the voters who put him in office.

First Williams managed to renegotiate Newfoundland and Labrador’s offshore oil revenues with Ottawa. Of course he had to back former PM Paul Martin into a corner in order to make him cough up billions of dollars in revenue, but it got done. That move provided the Province with the funds needed to decrease its debt, stabilize public sector pensions, address some long standing pay equity issues, begin improving infrastructure and balance the books. Not bad for a rookie.

Just a couple of months ago Williams made another bold move by taking a no nonsense stance with the oil industry’s biggest players. Simply put, he refused to allow Exxon Mobile and its partners to stroll in, extract the Province’s offshore oil, sell it at world record prices and walk away with hundreds of millions in additional tax breaks as icing on their corporate cakes. According to Exxon and some writers at the Globe and Mail, the offer was a sweet one the Province should have taken because it would have provided short term jobs helping the company ramp up for the big rape scene to take place offshore. Nice try Exxon, you too Globe but no thank-you.

Last week Williams decided to continue with his plans to place a Provincial lobbyist in Ottawa, something he tried unsuccessfully to do shortly after taking office. It seems he believes that the concept itself was a good one even if the structure, approach and perhaps even the man selected the first time around may have been flawed. Hopefully, with these lessons learned, the second time will be the charm.

Now in his latest attempt to add to his growing reputation as a hard line no nonsense leader Williams has hit a home run on his home field. After months of reviewing expressions of interest for development of the Lower Churchill power project, Williams made an announcement everyone in the Province has been waiting for with baited breath. Newfoundland and Labrador will develop the world class hydro project itself, without Quebec without Ontario and without anyone else for that matter. The Province will take all the risks and, hopefully as a result, it will reap all the benefits.

At this juncture I’ll say exactly what’s on the mind of nearly every person I’ve spoken with since that announcement, even at the risk of being accused of having a love in with the Premier.

“WAY TO GO DANNY!!!”

For the second time in as many months Premier Williams has told outside interests that we don’t need them to come in here, rape our resources, pocket the profits and give us the crumbs left over after they’ve picked the carcass clean. In making the announcement Williams has left the door open to dealing with outside interests, but the project will be a “made right here”.

Williams has said that he sees Ontario and Quebec as potential customers for the power, not owners in this project. Ontario is facing an energy crisis and the Quebec is expected to be in the same boat in a few years. The role of customer is a far cry from where both Province’s expected to be today. The Ontario government was so sure their joint bid with Quebec for the development would be accepted they their energy plan states that Ontario is, “…Working with Quebec to develop a major hydroelectric generation project at the Lower Churchill River in Labrador, from which 670 megawatts would come to Ontario.”

Nice try folks, but as Premier Williams said, if it’s good enough that everyone else to want, why shouldn’t we do it ourselves. By all accounts, nearly everyone in the Province agrees.

Williams’ tough attitude has prompted some Canadian columnists to brand the Premier a dictator, comparable to Hitler himself. As usual they’ve missed the point entirely. Williams isn’t doing anything more than the people of the Province want him to do. Unlike most politicians he is listening to his constituents. I know it’s revolutionary and unorthodox, it may even be difficult for some to comprehend, but if that’s the definition of a dictator we can use a lot more dictators around here.

As Bob Dylan once sang, “The times they are a changing.” The people of Newfoundland and Labrador are sick and tired of getting nothing but crumbs after bringing with them into confederation some of the Country’s most valuable natural resources.

The Province came into Canada boasting Atlantic fish stocks more abundant than could be found anywhere else in the world. After a few decades of management by Ottawa those stocks are now all but decimated and so too are the rural communities who depended on them for centuries.

The Upper Churchill River has been generating over 5 thousand megawatts of power for decades now. During all of that time Quebec Hydro has reaped billions in profits from the river while the owners, Newfoundlanders and Labradoreans, were forced into a deal that sees them run the generating station while barely receiving enough cash to keep the turbines turning. Adding insult to injury many people in Labrador, where the river resides, are forced to use diesel generated power to light their homes and the island part of the Province has to generate most of its power by burning heavy crude oil.

Billions of barrels of oil and gas sit off our coast and until recently it has benefited nobody except the oil companies and Ottawa. Some of those oil fields like the Ben Nevis field, over which talks broke down a short while ago, have been controlled and left untapped by multi-national oil interests for as long as 20 years. All the while the Province has continued to struggle just to survive.

(By the way, I hate to digress here but this whole oil issue really eats me up and I have to say something about it, sort of a rant within a rant if you like.

Everyday I hear people talking about the 2 billion dollars Ottawa “gave” Newfoundland and Labrador during the offshore revenue negotiations. I hear people say how terrible the deal was for the rest of Canada and how it was just another in a long line of hand outs to those “Dirty begging Newfies.” Well folks, for your enlightenment, even after that “handout” of money, which was generated by oil produced in the Province, Ottawa still receives over half of the royalties paid out by the oil companies while NL gets a less than half. We aren’t greedy. We like the deal because we like to contribute to the Country. We just don’t like being robbed by it.

Sorry about that, anyway back to the point at hand)

The Province brought with it into Confederation one of the world’s largest iron ore deposits, at Bell Island. Today those mines sit empty and deserted. Bell Island now supports only a handful of families. All the ore was stripped out and shipped away for processing someplace else years ago. All that’s left now are a few holes in the ground and a red rusty soil.

One of the world’s biggest nickel deposits is currently being mined at Voisey Bay in Labrador. As I write this column the ore is being stripped from the ground and shipped to Ontario for processing. According to INCO, they plan to build a smelter in the Province a few years down the road and will find ore elsewhere to make up for what they use now. I won’t hold my breath waiting for that to happen.

Once upon a time the Province was literally covered by virgin forests. Forests so beautiful they inspired the author of the Newfoundland anthem, the Ode to Newfoundland. One line in that heart wrenching song says, “When sun’s rays crown thy pine clad hills and summer spreads her hand.” As I look around me today I can pretty much count the number of pine trees left in the Province on the fingers of one hand, if I can find one at all.

The list of atrocities that have taken place in the Province since it joined Canada in 1949 is a long one. It’s a list that ends with a Province that has a population only the size of a small city yet with nothing to show for its world class resources except the highest unemployment, highest taxes and highest per capita debt of any Province in the Nation. Under those circumstances there’s little wonder the people of Newfoundland and Labrador are fed up, pissed off and aren’t going to take it any more. Now, at long last the Province appears at least, to have picked a leader who feels exactly the same way. Time will tell of course.

Something much of Canada fails to understand in this whole scenario is that most of the people in the Province simply don’t care anymore, not in the least. This feeling often arises when someone has been kicked around for too long. At some point that person realizes they don’t care what happens to them as a result of their actions. They just need to do something, anything at all. It’s what happens to a dog that has been beaten and starved until it finally bites its owner. It’s what happens to a battered spouse when he or she finally set the bed on fire while their partner sleeps. A point is reached where the action taken is just as important, perhaps even more so, than the results of that action and the consequences don’t matter in the least.

If industry, the Canadian government and even the public at large can understand this reality, they will have a much easier time over the next few years. Just so everyone understands it completely, especially the less than swift columnists at Canada’s National Newspapers, let me spell it out for you. The people of Newfoundland and Labrador don’t care if Exxon Mobile ever comes back to the negotiating table. They don’t care if the Ben Nevis oil field is ever utilized and they most certainly don’t care if the Province bankrupts itself developing the Lower Churchill. They just don’t care.

The reality is that Premier Williams in his efforts to support the very people who are supporting him, will either make Newfoundland and Labrador a very prosperous place to live or he’ll sink it so deep into the dark cold depths of the North Atlantic it’ll never be seen again. Either way it’s O.K. At this point the people of Newfoundland and Labrador just want to get busy living or get busy dying. The status quo is not an option.

Have you ever tried playing poker with someone who couldn’t care less if they lost everything? Well get ready folks, you’re about too.

26 comments:

Anonymous said...

Let's see if you "don't care" in 2 years when this province is empty of people and all your resources are STILL in the ground.
Danny Williams is not a great politician. Maybe he was a great business man but he is NOT doing this province any favours. What he is doing is building an image....the Premier who stood up for the common man and protected us all from the big bad world.

It scares the hell out of me what is going to become of this province. We are just too stubborn for our own good.
We NEED outside help to develope Hebron, Churchill, save the Fishery, etc. WE HAVE NO MONEY!! We are in debt up to our eyeballs and we have to have investors and the right people with the right knowledge and technology.
We are fools if we think we can shut out the world and "go it alone". Maybe one day....but not for a long time.
Wake up people! Williams does what he does for his own glory, and frankly, this blind faith and hero-worship really upsets me. Every time Williams drives away an investor he hammers another nail into Newfoundland and Labradors coffin.

Never mind "Way to go Danny"!! We need to be saying "Danny! What are you doing???"

WJM said...

Well folks, for your enlightenment, even after that “handout” of money, which was generated by oil produced in the Province,

No, it wasn't.

Ottawa still receives over half of the royalties paid out by the oil companies while NL gets a less than half.

Ottawa doesn't receive a single penny in oil royalties. The provincial government collects 100% of the royalties.

Read the Atlantic Accord 2005:

2. This document reflects an understanding between the Government of Canada and the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador that:

Newfoundland and Labrador already receives and will continue to receive 100 per cent of offshore resource revenues as if these resources were on land;

WJM said...

The Upper Churchill River has been generating over 5 thousand megawatts of power for decades now.

There is no such river as the "Upper Churchill River".

Adding insult to injury many people in Labrador, where the river resides, are forced to use diesel generated power to light their homes

Why didn't the provincial government of the day decide to use Labrador power in Labrador, instead of exporting it all?

Well folks, for your enlightenment, even after that “handout” of money, which was generated by oil produced in the Province,

Nope. It was generated by economic activity in every province and territory. It comes out of general Canadian federal revenues.

Ottawa still receives over half of the royalties paid out by the oil companies while NL gets a less than half.

Wrong. Ottawa does not collect even a single penny in offshore royalties. Nothing.

Read the original Atlantic Accord:

36. The principles of revenue sharing between Canada and Newfoundland with respect to revenues
from petroleum-related activities in the offshore area shall be the same as those which exist
between the Government of Canada and other hydrocarbon producing provinces with respect to
revenues from petroleum-related activities on land. The federal legislation implementing the
Accord, therefore, will permit the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador to establish and
collect resource revenues and provincial taxes of general application as if these petroleum-related
activities were on land within the province, through incorporation by reference of Newfoundland
laws (as amended from time to time), or through other appropriate legislative mechanisms.
37. On the basis of the foregoing, Newfoundland shall receive the proceeds of the following
revenues from petroleum related activity in the offshore area:
(a) royalties;


And the 2005 Accord:

2. This document reflects an understanding between the Government of Canada and the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador that:

Newfoundland and Labrador already receives and will continue to receive 100 per cent of offshore resource revenues as if these resources were on land;


The Province brought with it into Confederation one of the world’s largest iron ore deposits, at Bell Island.

Bell Island is hardly one of the world's largest iron ore deposits.

Today those mines sit empty and deserted. Bell Island now supports only a handful of families. All the ore was stripped out and shipped away for processing someplace else years ago.

Did Canada take the ore?

Guess what... the ore was mined and shipped out under pre-Confederation Newfoundland law. Confederation has nothing to do with the closure of Bell Island's mines.

One of the world’s biggest nickel deposits is currently being mined at Voisey Bay in Labrador. As I write this column the ore is being stripped from the ground and shipped to Ontario for processing.

I don't seem to hear many Newfoundlanders complain when Labrador minerals are sent to Newfoundland.

As I look around me today I can pretty much count the number of pine trees left in the Province on the fingers of one hand, if I can find one at all.

Forestry is ENTIRELY under provincial jurisdiction. The laws concerning forestry operations, again, go back to before Confederation. If the forests have been stripped, guess what? It's the fault of the government of Newfoundland.

It’s a list that ends with a Province that has a population only the size of a small city yet with nothing to show for its world class resources

Resources are not a very good way of building a diverse economy that supports a large population.

What natural resources do Singapore or Hong Kong have?

except the highest unemployment, highest taxes and highest per capita debt of any Province in the Nation.

No one held a gun to our heads and forced us to run deficits year after year.

they most certainly don’t care if the Province bankrupts itself developing the Lower Churchill.

Yikes! I certainly care whether the province bankrupts itself, on the so-called Lower Churchill or on anything else! No wonder the province is in such a mess, if no one cares about the public finances or not.

BornandBred said...

Well said. I remember the last couple of kicks at the can when N&L was trying to get a better deal on the Churchill

Falls "deal". There was discussions that if N&L were to disrupt the power source it would shake the markets and Quebec would be forced to negotiate a fair contract in the interests of demonstrating the reliability of the supply. We didn't pull the plug of course but there were no shortage of N&Lians that were shouting for them to flip the switch.

Your comment about the people of the province having been beaten into indifference is a valid one.

Anonymous said...

Great column, Patriot!

Very well said.

Anonymous said...

It's ExxonMOBIL not Exxon Mobile. God, no wonder you people can't get anything right.

NL-ExPatriate said...

Well spoken My Brother!
The more these Canadians and big business interests try to keep NL down the more determined I become to "Go it Alone"

We've been called Dumb Lazy Newfies for so long that the world and Canadians actually believe it to be true. Just look at the incidents where it is expressed in more than just a joke.
Margaret WindBag, Bill Wankoff, Globe and Pail, WJM, Paul Watshisname, editors of the Scum.

I'm sorry you can call me all the names you want but I know in my heart and soul that Newfoundlanders and Labradorians are amongst the best people on this earth. Hard working, Smart both in the ways of the world Nature as well books, caring, fun loving, beautiful people.

When Sunrays crown thy pine clad hills
And Summer spreads her hand
When silvern voices tune thy rills
We love thee smiling land
We love thee, we love thee
We love thee, smiling land.

When spreads thy cloak of shimm'ring white
At Winter's stern command
Thro' shortened day and starlit night
We love thee, frozen land
We love thee, we love thee
We love thee, frozen land.

When blinding storm gusts fret thy shore
And wild waves lash thy strand
Thro' spindrift swirl and tempest roar
We love thee, wind-swept land
We love thee, we love thee
We love thee, wind-swept land.

As loved our fathers, so we love
Where once they stood we stand
Their prayer we raise to heav'n above
God guard thee, Newfoundland
God guard thee, God guard thee
God guard thee, Newfoundland.

Anonymous said...

It was interesting in that your sentence "get busy living or get busy dying" came from the movie "The Shawshank Redemption".

About a man wrongly imprisoned for the death of his wife for decades,
who eventually escapes and goes to live in Mexico with his millions
that he has stolen from the prison captors that kept him.

Maybe this is how NL really feels about Canada?

Or were you referring to the exploited natural wildlife that you are killing off at alarming rates, along with the natural resources that you have all but decimated, admittedly?

Perhaps one day mother nature will get revenge on HER captors, and be free from the cruel hands of Newfoundlanders?

Do not blame Canada as a whole for the situation NL is in today. I am from there, and it was mostly Newfoundlanders themselves that ruined the cod stocks and chopped down all the trees.

It's much harder to accept responsibility for your own mistakes and involvement than it is to blame everyone and everything else around you for it.

Anonymous said...

Patriot, in the time Williams has been there he has watched your unemployment rise and has not created a single job.

Maybe he should spend less time playing cards and more time doing what he was elected to do.

Anonymous said...

I see WJM telling half truths and twisting things like talking about a couple of people and making it sound like a force at 5 wing or saying the Feds get nothing from the offshore royalties. WJM why don't you just tell everyone who you really work for because you aren't speaking independently.

Either lies or stupidity is my gues, take your pick but I doubt it's the latter.

The time has come and a revolution is on the way.

Patriot said...

The reality is that a member of the board of directors for Quebec Hydro was also on the board of the company running the upper churchill project for NL. Because of this clear conflict (being a buyer of power and the seller) the board member knew of the financial difficulties of the project and delayed the signing of any deal until the company was a month or so from bankruptcy. Then Quebec Hydro suddenly introduced the "modified" contract that was signed.

Basically they knew that it was a matter of either signing that contract or going bankrupt and the entire project failing after all the money had been spent.

Sure sounds like there was a big choice there right?

Also, to WJM who quoted the accord document. The reality is that NL keeps 100% of its royalties but that does not equate to 100% of the overall royalties paid by the oil companies. The fact is it equates to less than half of the royalties paid by them. Get your facts straight.

Anonymous said...

Western Canadian company headhunts in N.L.
Last updated May 10 2006 03:59 PM NDT

CBC News

It's a sign of the times in Newfoundland and Labrador – a company from
Western Canada is here this week as part of a cross-country tour to
recruit workers.

Finning (Canada), which sells, rents and services Caterpillar and
other large machinery primarily in Alberta and British Columbia, wants
to hire 1,600 workers over the next four years, from heavy duty
technicians and apprentices to sales and service workers.

Times are so good that the Edmonton-based company is planning to
double its size – and times are so bad in Newfoundland and Labrador
that there are plenty of people heading west for work.

Little Harbour resident Donald Upshall works fishing crab and cod from
his 34-foot boat. However, with prices and quotas being cut,
39-year-old Upshall says he can't afford to continue and is
considering moving west for employment.

"It's a huge career choice," Upshall said. "I'm not very happy about
it, but time's come to move on. So Alberta is where the jobs and the
opportunities are … I don't see them here."

Dale Careen, who already works in Northern B.C. as a gas plant
operator, wants a job that will employ him until retirement.

"If you get used to a certain quality of life, I guess wherever you
can find that quality of life you've got to go for it," said Careen,
31, from Point Lance on the Cape Shore. "There are no opportunities,
really, here for me."

But there seem to be plenty of opportunities in Western Canada and
Shaun Bilodeau, a recruiter with Finning, hopes his sales pitch will
attract workers from this province.

"A mechanic working 40 hours a week under the bare minimum is going to
make at least $60,000 dollars per year," Bilodeau said.

So far, he said, response to the recruiting drive in this province has
been good.

WJM said...

I see WJM telling half truths

Which "half truths"? Be specific.

and twisting things like talking about a couple of people

What "couple of people"? Be specific.

and making it sound like a force at 5 wing or saying the Feds get nothing from the offshore royalties.

The feds didn't, don't and won't.

This has to be repeated for the umpteenth time: THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT DOES NOT COLLECT ONE RED CENT IN OFFSHORE OIL AND GAS ROYALTIES.

EVERY PENNY of those royalties go to the provincial governments of Newfoundland and Labrador, or Nova Scotia.

Repeat: THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT DOESN'T COLLECT ANY OFFSHORE OIL OR GAS ROYALTIES FROM OFF OF ATLANTIC CANADA.

Please provide proof to the contrary.

Either lies or stupidity is my gues, take your pick but I doubt it's the latter.

Anyone who says that the federal government collects offshore oil royalties is either lying or stupid. Which is it in your case, brave anonymous person?

WJM said...

Also, to WJM who quoted the accord document. The reality is that NL keeps 100% of its royalties but that does not equate to 100% of the overall royalties paid by the oil companies.

Yes, it does.

ONLY THE PROVINCE COLLECTS ROYALTIES.

I have to repeat this, since there are a lot of dense people out there who don't get this:

ONLY THE PROVINCE COLLECTS ROYALTIES.

Royalties are the tax on the resource as it comes out of the ground.

ONLY THE PROVINCE COLLECTS ROYALTIES.

Not the federal government.

The fact is it equates to less than half of the royalties paid by them. Get your facts straight.

Get your facts straight. Please provide a source for your information.

The federal government collects income and corporate taxes related to offshore oil activity, but this is true of EVERY industry.

The federal government does NOT collect royalties.

Not a penny.

Anyone who says otherwise is a liar, or stupid.

Which is it?

If the federal government DOES collect royalties, you are hereby challenged to come up with the amount.

Don't believe what you hear on Open Line.

Find out for us: How many dollars did Ottawa collect in "royalties" last year?

Anonymous said...

WJM>> Sorry but your wrong on this, you sound right but you clearly don't know how the industry works:

Royalties are not a tax on extraction but a fee for the transfer of public resources to private industry.

The FG and the PG's have an agreemen on which portion of the royalties go to each level of government. For example in the NWT the FG between 1994-2004 collected $120 million in royalites at a rate of 5.4% to encourage business the FG collects 25.5% in Alberta.

So no the PG's do not collect 100% of the revenue.

Anonymous said...

Sorry wjm, your out of your comfort zone here. Ottawa collects royalties. Google: "Ottawa +Royalties". Your just wrong.

Anonymous said...

----------------------
Bell Island is hardly one of the world's largest iron ore deposits.
----------------------

Really? And we should take your word over the word of historian Rick Rennie at Memorial University:

"...The iron ore mines of Bell Island were a different matter. Opened by the Nova Scotia Steel and Coal Company (Scotia) in 1895, by 1900 the Bell Island mines had become one of the leading sources of iron ore in the world, and Scotia had been joined in 1899 by the Dominion Steel Corporation..."

WJM said...

The FG and the PG's have an agreemen on which portion of the royalties go to each level of government.

Yes. And in the case of offshore oil of gas in NS and NL, and onshore minerals in every province (it's different in the territories), the agreement is this: THE PROVINCE GETS 100%.

For example in the NWT the FG between 1994-2004 collected $120 million in royalites

Yip. The NWT is a territory, not a province.

at a rate of 5.4% to encourage business the FG collects 25.5% in Alberta.

Collects 25.5% of what?

So no the PG's do not collect 100% of the revenue.

Never said they did. The federal government collects things like corporate and personal income taxes associated with the economic activity generated by the oil and gas industry. The same is true in respect of the auto industry or the paper industry or the corner store industry or the banking industry.

However, outside the territories, (and the occasional on-reserve oil or gas well or mine/quarry) the federal government does NOT collect mineral or petroleum royalties.

Sorry to burst a myth, but it has to be done.

I ask again for the people who "know" otherwise: how much did Ottawa collect in offshore oil and gas ROYALTIES in the last year for which figures are available?

Thought so...

And ever-so-brave anonymous... what was that Google exercise supposed to teach me? Provide me with a more specific link. Thanks.

Anonymous said...

you use to speak highly of him...once upon a seal hunt....you would have thought he was God! oh me oh my.

Anonymous said...

I don't know who wrote the "Ode to Newfoundland" but they obvioulsy had a few screws loose. That song annoys the hell out of me and it's waaay over-played. Try the National Anthem once in a while.
Smiling land?? Land doesn't smile last I checked.
Also, I spent some winters here....the storms aren't exactly something to sing about.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous, the Ode To Newfoundland was our national anthem before we joined Canada. And no, the land does not literally smile, it's a metaphor you literary-numbnut. As for the storms, I may only be 18, and live in central, but I can think of some storms I've seen that were plenty to sing about. Though global warming has been toning down our winter weather lately.

Mr. Spog said...

The last time Newfoundlanders "didn't care" about risking bankruptcy, they ended up losing their national independence.

State bankruptcy doesn't mean walking away from one's debts, it means being squeezed dry forever, as they've discovered in Latin America.

Lady_Celes said...

Yes, read that entire Accord document and also the new document that Mr. Williams negotiated if anyone has a link to that? "Follow the money" as they say in all crime investigations and be very careful when doing business with Quebec! New Brunswick has a problem with them because of their protectionism laws that allow Quebec business to invest in New Brunswick at the same time it blocks our companies from expanding into their province. This really hurts our construction industry as their companies bid lower and get the big contracts in our province instead of New Brunswick owned businesses but we are not even allowed to bid on the contracts in their province!
"True blue Canadian" = Conservatives today but in the past it was a representation of Irish Catholic's, the enemy of Irish Protestants. The Irish were the most hated group of people to come to the Western World. Many settled in NL and had a reputation for being lazy, drunkards etc. Not much has changed in Ireland in all these years of fighting and not much has changed in Canada since those ancestors brought their fight to their new country. Is it any wonder that the same discrimination continues today? Believe me, when it comes to who gets to earn the money, Newfoundlanders will be last on the list unless you join together, get well informed on these matters and start fighting the good fight for your rights instead of running away to Alberta every time the going gets tough! Let me guess, if it's anything like New Brunswick, it's the Protestant communities being driven out while the true blues and their partners in Quebec run away with the profits! Don't let them get away with this!

Anonymous said...

"summer spreads her hand"? what? summer doesn't have any hands!!
"cloak of shimmering white" Land doesn't wear a cloak!
"fret thy shore" shores cant fret!

C'mon... you know "smiling land" isn't a literal meaning.

Personnally I think the Canadian anthem is lame. It's critizised by everybody; feminists, various religious groups (and anti-religious groups), First nations and immigrants.
And the french version is completly different than the English version, hows that for national unity? Wouldn't you want people in all parts of the country saying the same thing when they sing the national anthem?

Anonymous said...

I *KNOW* it's not a literal meaning...my point was that it's dribble.

Anonymous said...

WJM: My name is A. Morris and I don't live in Newfoundland and haven't for 45 years but I am still interested in what goes on there...got it? I haven't signed up through goggle for some ficticous account name which allows me to write a blog because I DON'T WANT TO DO SO. I am also not associated with any other anon comments here. Mr. Higgins has provide a medium as in Anon unlike your friend Mr. Hollett so people who are not bloggers can present their comments...get it? You sound like a farty old arse who needs to know who everyone is writing comments....WHY?...so you can get some sort of political revenge? Or perhaps you want to stock these people? Who are you, a political science major who doesn't have a sense of humour or able to understand what the "Ode To Newfoundland" means? The last time I looked, it is still a free country where people a given the right to express themselves whether right or wrong....get it?
Now, Mr. Higgins I wish to make a comment about your blog. If a government official in Newfoundland or for that matter, anyone interested in the well-being of Newfoundland were to look into the way Norway has managed its off shore oil contracts, it would be a prime example as to the way Newfoundland could proceed with natural rescource production in anything. Norway receives 80% ROYALTIES while ExxonMobil gets 20%for producing oil and Norwegians are 4 million in population. Their health care is one of the best in the world unlike Canada especially Newfoundland. Their education system is the best in the world as listed by the UN. Canada used to be second but has dropped to 8th place behind Australia. Newfoundland has been robbed blind by people putting their blind trust into Primiers who have proven themselves to be con-artists or, walking around with stupid ideas like cucumbers. Danny Williams happens to be a Primier who gives his government salary to charity....good for him. He is wealthy enough to do so. I bet he does have a game plan though. Perhaps he might want to run for the PM's job. If so, he'll have to work diligently in order to perfect his French. Everyone in politics has a price and it is up to us to keep those pricy politicans on the straight an narrow. After all, it is our country and/or province and what we do refects on how our country and/or province is run. In other words, we need to be loud and clear, informed and able to voice our opinion without arrogant attack.